Recently I installed one of the “flat icon” sets for LibreOffice which suits my tastes nicely. I also use the Alternative dialog Find & Replace extension and have its icon on my toolbar:
It makes an uneasy partner (shall we say!) in this context. I have tried to find out how to change the icon of an extension, but the “Alternative Searching” toolbar does not show up in the Tools > Customise... menu, nor does the Tools > Extension Manager... give access to this kind of modification.
I have seen a previous answer to a question about the location of toolbar icons, but this seems not to cover extensions.
Any help out there? I live in hope!
UPDATE: Result after help (see accepted answer, plus comments, below):

Actually, though it’s *_26.bmp, not *_24.bmp. I’m not quite sure how one gets the “transparent” bg with a BMP, but I just went with
Getting rid of the “halo” was getting irksome, so I