Impress on Raspberry pi only showing the presenter screen

I have 2 monitors connected to my pi5
They are configured side by side
I want the presentation to appear on one of them and the presenter window on the other.

Every time I “present” the slide show, the first slide appears then disappears behind the presenter screen and that is all I ever see.

I’ve tried configuring the two displays on top of each other but this only shows me the presentation, not the presenter view

It seems I can only get just the presenter view or just the presentation…

Any ideas?